[Product-Developers] How attached to POI issue trackers are we?

Ross Patterson me at rpatterson.net
Fri Feb 10 05:23:22 UTC 2012


Jon Stahl <jonstahl at gmail.com> writes:

> On Thu, Feb 9, 2012 at 7:27 PM, T. Kim Nguyen
> <nguyen at uwosh.edu> wrote:
>> I'm sure there would be wide support for allowing existing Poi on
>> plone.org to continue being used, and not allowing new Poi to be
>> created on plone.org.
>>
>> If Poi eventually are to be shut off entirely on plone.org then it
>> would be good to have a moderately decent export / import mechanism;
>> I have no idea if there is such a thing today, however.
>
>>> We can and should be smart about the software we commit ourselves to
>>> maintain.  Our community time, energy and ingenuity is valuable and
>>> should be focused on making a better CMS, not supporting and maintaining
>>> a very old, and passable but not terribly good issue tracker.  Our
>>> users' time, energy, and experience is also very valuable and should be
>>> cared for when they report problems with or request features of the
>>> add-ons they use.  It is not only appropriate, but important for all of
>>> this to be taken into account when asking the kind of questions being
>>> asked here.  It is also appropriate and important to be asking these
>>> kinds of questions.
>>>
>>> Ros
>
> Ross, Kim-
>
> Thanks, obviously you see where this conversation could be headed.
> ;-) I'm trying hard not to jump to any conclusions, though, so... to
> push you to answer a more specific question:
>
> As an add-on product dev/contributor, are there any specific Poi
> instances you are the owner or a significant user of that you,
> personally, would be sorry to see go away?

No, nor am I aware of anything I've contributed to in terms of Poi
tickets (reporting, commenting, fixing/contributing) that I'd be sorry
to see go away.  In general, as long as there were a well thought out
and long phased sunset, I can't see any problem from my personal
experience.

Ross



More information about the Product-Developers mailing list