[Framework-Team] Re: PLIP discussion summary

whit whit at longnow.org
Fri Oct 28 20:01:55 UTC 2005


Alec Mitchell wrote:

>Whit,
>
>	Thanks for volunteering to put a document together. 
>
thank you for such a nice concise summary of your views.  i'm forwarding 
this back out to the rest of the list.

>Here is a summary of the 
>discussion from my point of view:
>
>100 (Selenium):  -1 No urgent need for integration into plone core.  The 3rd 
>party framework works and and will continue to do so.  People can write 
>selenium tests for plone and their own products easily without selenium being 
>directly integrated into plone.
>
>102 (PlonePAS):  +1 This is very much needed as GRUF is inflexible and 
>unmaintained.  However, we need to ensure that migration from existing GRUF 
>(and pre-GRUF) instances is well supported.
>
>105 (Views in Plone): +1 To the concept.  Though this PLIP is not something 
>that will result in specific code which needs to be reviewed and approved 
>(except perhaps the global_defines stuff), it does outline one of the major 
>goals of the 2.2 release.  Without this 2.2 is a bit meaningless.
>
>106 (Views for Nav elements):  +1 this could potentially result in some 
>speedup, and allows for reimplementation of some of the cruftier code in 
>plone.  We need to flesh out what the new view-ified portlet architecture 
>will look like, because we are going to be stuck with it, the PlonePortlets 
>folks should certainly be included, as I'm sure they have opinions on this.
>
>107 (Five based navtree): +1 The current usage of an AT schema element to 
>determine navigation visibility is hacky and is a really bad example of 
>mixing content with presentation (both Tiran and I argued against this 
>originally, but the UI folks won out).  I am not at all familiar with 
>MenuGenerator, and what it provides, or how exactly we will make this 
>dependency soft.  A cursory look makes me think that it is a complex (though 
>nice) bit of code to be bringing in just to make one tree display.
>
>108 (zope3 i18n): +1 Hannosch has done great work here, and there are many 
>compelling reasons to go in this direction, and the downsides are minimal.
>
>Alec
>
>  
>


-- 
 
 | david "whit" morriss 
 |
 | contact :: http://public.xdi.org/=whit 

 "If you don't know where you are,  
  you don't know anything at all"        
                                     
  Dr. Edgar Spencer, Ph.D., 1995     


 "I like to write code like  
 other ppl like to tune their 
 cars or 10kW hifi equipment..."
 
 Christian Heimes, 2004


-------------- next part --------------
A non-text attachment was scrubbed...
Name: whit.vcf
Type: text/x-vcard
Size: 181 bytes
Desc: not available
URL: <http://lists.plone.org/pipermail/plone-framework-team/attachments/20051028/9a830c59/attachment.vcf>


More information about the Framework-Team mailing list